Myth: A Carbon Neutral Desal Plant

moss landingThe Santa Cruz City Council as well as the Board of the Soquel Creek Water District expressed their desire that the proposed desal plant be carbon neutral. There is a big difference between that desire and the feasibility of accomplishing it.

The obvious way to make a desal plant carbon neutral would be to power it with renewable energy. However, this option was dismissed by the 2005 EIR for the Integrated Water Plan. “… these sources are not feasible at this time for power requirements typical of large-scale industrial-type applications.” This statement is misleading. Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Conservation Lessons Video

The one-hour video is now online of our forum on Conservation: Lessons Learned, with Conner Everts discussing Australia and Ron Duncan discussing the Soquel Creek Water District. Or watch the video on Community TV, Channel 27, Thursdays 8/14, 8/21, 8/28, and 9/4 at 9 PM.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Water Neutral Growth

Growth Increases Our Drought Risk

Santa Cruz needs water policies that will allow reasonable growth to continue without increasing demand for water.That way we can effectively manage our drought risk. A 2004 City Water Department report(1) put it this way:

“Continuing to provide water to new customers upon request, as is the current practice, may do harm to existing customers by making the potential water shortage situation worse than it would otherwise be.” Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Equitable Water Pricing: Who Pays and Who Benefits from Water Supply Strategies?

 People affected by change have to be deeply involved in the crafting of solutions—they are going to pay for them either economically or through changes in how they live. We need more democracy, not less.   - William Ruckelshaus, the first director of the Environmental Protection Agency

Our water supply predicament in mid Santa Cruz County would benefit from “more democracy”. We’re going to have to pay for water solutions, use less water, or both. Arriving at our choice through democratic means will be a challenge. Our community’s ability to achieve consensus on water solutions could be undermined by the disparity between those customers who are used to using a lot of water and those who use much less. How likely is it that customers whose water use is within sustainable levels will support an expensive water supply project? Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Water Transfers Between Districts

ACTION STEP: The Santa Cruz Council should direct the Water Department to:

1)    Apply now for water rights permission to immediately transfer water to Soquel Creek District
2)    Enter negotiations with Soquel Creek Water District, Scotts Valley Water District and San Lorenzo Valley Water District to contract for reciprocal water exchanges.
3)    Open the Habitat Conservation Plan (HCP) negotiations to participation from the County and neighboring water districts in order to facilitate fisheries agency approval of a water transfer plan. The HCP process should also be public.
4)    Report on the cost and benefits of pre-treatment of turbid water and the “Lochquifer Strategy”.

Background:
The concept of water transfers is that Santa Cruz would draw San Lorenzo River water, treat it, and send it to Soquel Creek Water District and Scotts Valley Water District in winter months when there is more than enough water in the river to satisfy fish reproduction requirements. Those districts, which are 100% dependent on groundwater, would be able to reduce their pumping of groundwater during the winter, allowing the aquifer to recharge.

From the point of view of Santa Cruz, water transfers is a water storage strategy. Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

EIR flaw of the month

To download the complete comment from California Department of Fish and Wildlife, click here.

In what may become a regular feature, we reprint comments on the Draft EIR for the desal project. A look at some of the 400 comments from agencies, experts, and the public lead us to conclude that the Draft EIR is flawed beyond repair. If the City chooses to spend more money on “fixing” the flaws for a final EIR, the only credible result would be a fair assessment of alternatives to the project, and a conclusion that the project is not needed.

In this newsletter we feature the comment from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW): Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Carbon Offsets Debunked

Myth & Reality

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Conservation Fatigue?

At their April 16th 7pm meeting, the Soquel Creek Water District Board will consider asking customers to cut back on their water use by 15%. This measure is long overdue. Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Desal Music Video

Check out this 6 minute video “Clear and Free” in which local artists sing in celebration of our home and watershed—and the need to take care of it. Here are the lyrics: Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

How We Got in this Mess: Soquel Creek District

I like the definition of environmental sustainability as “providing for current needs without degrading the ecosystem that will support future generations”.  We know our water use is not sustainable when saltwater is steadily intruding into the groundwater in the Pajaro Valley, forcing the abandonment of agricultural wells along the coast. In mid-County, the Purisima Aquifer is in danger of the same fate as its southern neighbor. And in the San Lorenzo River watershed and streams along the county’s north coast, the populations of steelhead have declined precipitously since 1970. Coho salmon can no longer be found in the San Lorenzo River.
How did we get here? Were there signs along the way that could have given us a clue that we were headed past sustainable water use? And how do we best achieve sustainable use? Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment